Official GFX rating Thread

[subesh]

We've all been looking forward to it and now we have it. Our very own GFX rating thread. Do you have a template, banner/header, logo or even button that you want to get opinions on? Then Post them here and give a chance for everyone here to share the comments and criticism (CNC) on it.
(Keep these graphics clean and G rated as we have people from all age groups on this forum). All Works of Gfx must have at least one comment before posting another work of gfx.

When Posting Make sure to Do so in this format:

When Asking for Advice follow this format:
- Image
- What it is, what it's for or why you made it.
- What you think about it and if you want any specific suggestions.

When Replying or Rating do do in this format:
- Rating out of 10. Example (1/10 and so on with 1 being the lowest and 10 being the highest)
- What you think they did nicely and what they can improve.
- Then if you want someone to rate yours put it here under your comments and ask for rating.

[subesh]

I will start this off with a header I made for a contest.

Here is a header I made for a contest. I didn't win the contest but I just kept it because I really liked what I did. I just want to hear some CnC (Comments and criticism) about it so that I can improve my future works of art. Please give me a rating out of 10 and tell me why as well.
Thanks

[twinklestar]

overall it is nice. i rate it 9/10

you could work on moving the 'shingle nation' a few more to the lower right.

'hosted at myupload.org' could also have been smaller since it is irrelevant.

[Jerlene]

I made a couple of rank images for forums and what not. What do you think? Took me all of two minutes.

JeRanks Pink Edition



JeRanks Green Edition

[Jerlene]

This is a good thread so I decided to sticky it.

[Jerlene]

This is where you can find logos that I made[from Paint.NET] -
Index of /images

[willyoumind]

Hmm..., A very straighfoward and easy to understand guide here, Subesh...

BY the way, Jerlene. I loved your JeRank Pink Edition rank images, it's looks so stylish and innovative to me

[Jerlene]

Thanks. You check out my portfolio?